Jared Padalecki’s Supernatural Revival Idea Would Bring Sam and Dean Back from Heaven with No Idea Why

Updated

Jensen Ackles and Jared Padalecki at the Supernatural panel during Comic-Con International 2017 at the San Diego Convention Center.

Jared Padalecki’s idea for a Supernatural revival would leave Sam and Dean Winchester investigating their own resurrection. After the series finale reunited the brothers in Heaven, his proposed sequel would put them back on Earth with no explanation for how they got there or what brought them back.

“They’ve got work to do. They don’t know exactly what yet. They don’t know why they’re even there, but they have to sleuth it out,” Padalecki said while discussing a possible return.

The Paley Center For Media's 35th Annual PaleyFest Los Angeles - "Supernatural" - Arrivals
Jensen Ackles and Jared Padalecki together at the Dolby Theatre in Hollywood for the Supernatural PaleyFest panel in March 2018. Photo by Emma McIntyre / Getty Images.

He envisions four episodes running 90 minutes each, with filming taking three or four months. His production model is Gilmore Girls: A Year in the Life, the limited revival he appeared in after playing Dean Forester on the original series.

Padalecki’s premise picks up after a particularly final goodbye. In “Carry On,” which aired November 19, 2020, Dean dies after being impaled during a vampire hunt. Sam lives long enough to raise a son named Dean before dying of old age. The brothers eventually find each other again in Heaven.

Jared Padalecki
Jared Padalecki photographed by Emma McIntyre / Getty Images.

Padalecki called that finale “my favorite episode of all time” before it aired. His sequel idea would open a new mystery after an ending he’s publicly embraced, with the reason for the brothers’ return still unwritten. He’s also ruled out a prequel with the original leads because he and Jensen Ackles have aged beyond their early Winchester years.

The shorter format has been on his mind for a while. In June 2024, Padalecki described a similar Gilmore Girls-style return on Tommy DiDario’s podcast, I’ve Never Said This Before. The resurrection mystery gives that long-discussed format a starting point.

For a series that began with brothers investigating urban legends, there’s a familiar appeal to giving them a case they can’t explain. Creator Eric Kripke described the original ambition in 2009 as making “a horror movie every week.” Padalecki’s outline leaves the central questions open: who brought the Winchesters back, and what do they need them to do?

The Paley Center For Media's 35th Annual PaleyFest Los Angeles - "Supernatural" - Arrivals
Jensen Ackles and Jared Padalecki together at the Dolby Theatre in Hollywood for the Supernatural PaleyFest panel in March 2018. Photo by Emma McIntyre / Getty Images.
The Paley Center For Media's 35th Annual PaleyFest Los Angeles - "Supernatural" - Arrivals
Jensen Ackles, Jared Padalecki, and Misha Collins arrive together at PaleyFest Los Angeles for the Supernatural panel at the Dolby Theatre on March 20, 2018. Photo by Emma McIntyre / Getty Images.
Comic-Con International 2016 - "Supernatural" Special Video Presentation And Q&A
Jared Padalecki throws a hand in the air at the Supernatural Q&A panel during Comic-Con International 2016 in San Diego, while Jensen Ackles smiles beside him. Photo by Kevin Winter / Getty Images.
"Supernatural" Special Video Presentation - Comic-Con International 2013
At the San Diego Convention Center, Jensen Ackles rests a hand against his cheek while seated alongside Jared Padalecki at the Supernatural special video presentation panel during Comic-Con International 2013 on July 21. Photo by Kevin Winter / Getty Images.
2019 Summer TCA Press Tour - Day 13
Padalecki and Ackles share a laugh together at the 2019 Summer TCA Press Tour at The Beverly Hilton Hotel on August 4, 2019. Photo by Amy Sussman / Getty Images.
2019 CW Network Upfront
At New York City Center on May 16, 2019, Jared Padalecki stands alone for a photo during the 2019 CW Network Upfront, dressed in a navy suit with an open-collar white shirt. Photo by Dia Dipasupil / Getty Images.
The Paley Center For Media's 35th Annual PaleyFest Los Angeles - "Supernatural" - Arrivals
A close-up portrait of Padalecki on the red carpet at PaleyFest Los Angeles for Supernatural at the Dolby Theatre on March 20, 2018. Photo by Emma McIntyre / Getty Images.
The Paley Center For Media's 35th Annual PaleyFest Los Angeles - "Supernatural" - Arrivals
At the Dolby Theatre on March 20, 2018, the Paley Center for Media’s 35th Annual PaleyFest Los Angeles honored Supernatural — with Jensen Ackles and Jared Padalecki pictured together on the red carpet. Photo by Emma McIntyre / Getty Images.
The Paley Center For Media's 35th Annual PaleyFest Los Angeles - "Supernatural" - Inside
Misha Collins, Jensen Ackles, Jared Padalecki, and Alexander Calvert share a laugh during the Supernatural panel at PaleyFest Los Angeles inside the Dolby Theatre on March 20, 2018. Photo by Emma McIntyre / Getty Images.
Comic-Con International 2017 - "Supernatural" Panel
Microphones in hand, Jensen Ackles and Jared Padalecki share a laugh at the Supernatural panel during Comic-Con International in San Diego on July 23, 2017. Photo by Kevin Winter / Getty Images.
1 / 10

Meet the author