Inde Navarrette Says Playing the Real Nikki in Obsession’s Trivia Bar Scene Was Harder Than She Expected

Updated

Inde Navarrette posing at the Getty Images Portrait Studio for IMDb at InterContinental Toronto Centre

Inde Navarrette says her hardest scene to shoot in Obsession was the trivia bar scene, whenever she had to switch back to the ordinary Nikki who exists before the wish.

“I had spent so much time playing wish Nikki that going into real Nikki was really, really difficult,” she said in a Nov 13 video interview. “Yeah, playing real Nikki was actually harder than I had anticipated.”

The trivia bar scene was filmed last, as a reshoot of the film’s beginning. Navarrette said the immediate move from “Wish Nikki” to “Real Nikki” felt strange.

She’d grown “so protective over ‘Wish Nikki’ and so in love with her. I could play her for the rest of my life,” she said in a Cosmopolitan interview.

Getty Images Portrait Studio Presented By IMDb And IMDbPro At The Intercontinental Hotel Toronto, 2026
Inde Navarrette, star of ‘Obsession,’ photographed at the IMDb Portrait Studio during the Toronto film festival on September 13, 2026. Photo by Gareth Cattermole / Getty Images.

In Curry Barker’s film, Bear (Michael Johnston) wishes that his music-store coworker Nikki will love him, and the wish takes away her agency. That leaves Navarrette roughly the first 15 minutes, by her own count, to establish who Nikki really is before another version of her takes over.

The early bar conversation carries much of that work. Discussing it in May, Navarrette said Nikki circles back to hear Bear out because she genuinely cares about him.

Barker has said Navarrette brought qualities to the everyday Nikki that weren’t in his original sweet-girl-next-door conception.

“How much can I build in that time to where you understand why Bear is in love with her, you yearn for her to be saved? You also grieve the life that she’s losing,” she said in a Sept 24 interview.

Meet the author