Tarantino Said He Didn’t Care for Matthew Lillard. Mike Flanagan Cast Him in Carrie and Got Him Electrocuted Again

Rahul Kohli and Matthew Lillard at the Carrie premiere event

Last December, Quentin Tarantino sat down on The Bret Easton Ellis Podcast and said, “I don’t care for Owen Wilson, I don’t care for Matthew Lillard.” Four days later, at GalaxyCon in Columbus, Ohio, Lillard told fans what that felt like: “It hurts your feelings. It f—in’ sucks.”

Carrie — Post
Amber Midthunder and Matthew Lillard on set for the upcoming Carrie, directed by Mike Flanagan. Photo by Robert Falconer / Prime.

He went further later, calling the stretch of criticism “like living through your own wake.”

40th Annual Santa Barbara International Film Festival: US Premiere Of "Horizon: An American Saga - Chapter 2"
Quentin Tarantino at The Arlington Theatre in Santa Barbara for the 40th Annual Santa Barbara International Film Festival, February 7, 2025. Photo by Robin L Marshall / Getty Images.

Hollywood pushed back. George Clooney said he’d “be honored to work with those actors. Honored!” James Gunn posted photos of Lillard, calling him “one of my favorite guys (and actors)” for “no reason.”

Matthew Lillard posing for a portrait
Matthew Lillard poses for a portrait. Courtesy of Prime / Robin L Marshall / Getty Images.

Lillard said colleagues who’ve worked with him recognize his range, yet he doesn’t think Hollywood sees him as a leading man, even though audiences show up for him. When Tommy DiDario asked on the I’ve Never Said This Before podcast whether Lillard felt valued by the industry, Lillard answered, “No. Not really.”

Then came the part Lillard didn’t have to wait for. After working on The Life of Chuck, director Mike Flanagan told him, “You’re now in the Flanafam,” and, “I have a part for you in ‘Carrie.’”

That part is Principal Henry Grayle, a character earlier screen versions of Carrie left offscreen entirely. Flanagan’s series on Prime Video gives him the job, and it gives Lillard a familiar exit: Grayle is electrocuted at the prom, a nod to the way Lillard’s Stu Macher died in Scream.

Carrie — NY Premiere
Matthew Lillard, Samantha Sloyan, and Summer H. Howell step out in New York City on September 28, 2026 for Prime Video’s PROMiere event celebrating the new series “Carrie.” Photo by Clark Studios.

“I get to get electrocuted again!” Lillard told him.

Carrie — NY Premiere
Matthew Lillard, Amber Midthunder, Kate Siegel, and castmates gather in New York City on September 28, 2026 for Prime Video’s premiere event for the new series “Carrie.” Photo by Clark Studios for Prime Video.

Meet The Author

January Nelson is a writer, editor, and dreamer. She writes about astrology, games, love, relationships, and entertainment. Her favorite horror movies tend to be more on the artsy side.