A Fan Joke Casts the Body’s Four Leads in Pretty Little Liars, Yellowjackets, Glee and Bottoms

Updated

The four lead characters of Netflix's "The Body"

A viral post about Netflix’s “The Body” has settled on the funniest way to describe its four leads: each one is acting like she’s on a completely different show.

On November 16, X user @girltwinkdyke, who goes by emi, wrote that Anya thinks she’s on “Pretty Little Liars,” Lisbeth thinks she’s on “Yellowjackets,” Elise thinks she’s on “Glee,” and Katie thinks she’s on “Bottoms.” The post spawned spinoffs, including one that moved Elise to “Gossip Girl” and Lisbeth to an Ethel Cain album.

The joke works because the show really is all of those tones at once. “The Body” dropped on Netflix on November 11 and follows the Lions, a clique of Catholic school girls closing ranks after a 2004 Halloween party where they dose a new dancer and jokingly offer her up as a virgin sacrifice.

The four lead characters of Netflix's "The Body"
A scene from Netflix’s “The Body,” featuring the four lead characters. (via @thebodynetflix)

Creator Quinn Shephard has described the tone as “The Crucible” meets “Jennifer’s Body,” or Regina George taking up devil worship.

From there, every label lands. Anya Butler, the closeted queen bee, is haunted by visions and guilt over what happened to a girl named Grace, which is the paranoid-mystery register of “Pretty Little Liars.”

Lisbeth, the blackmailing survivalist who prints the team’s old AIM chats, leads an exorcism and takes an axe to a snake, carries the feral “Yellowjackets” energy.

Faking a Grace vision in church, Elise seizes, winks at Anya, and goes on to nearly kiss her during a regionals duet, “Glee” by way of a horror movie. And Katie, the sarcastic, laid-back one standing off to the side cracking jokes at the hysteria, is pure “Bottoms.”

None of it is a plot point. The characters never name those four shows, and no cast interview backs up the mapping. It’s a fan reading the room, and the room agreed.

The four lead characters of Netflix's "The Body"
A scene from Netflix’s “The Body,” featuring the four lead characters. (via @thebodynetflix)
Young woman with two braids and a red feathery hair accessory sits at a wooden table with a Starbucks cup, looking down, in a dimly lit room.
A scene from Netflix’s ‘The Body’ captures one of the Lions clique in a dark-lit hall, braided hair and a fluffy red hair accessory in hand, a Starbucks cup on the table nearby. Credit: @thebodynetflix
1 / 2

Meet the author