A Weird Horror Comedy About a Cursed New England Island Just Broke the Emmys Record with 14 Wins

A bearded man in a tuxedo and bow tie kisses one of two gold Emmy Award statuettes he holds, grinning, in front of an Emmy-branded backdrop.

“Widow’s Bay” swept all 6 categories it entered Monday night, bringing its single-season total to 14 Emmys and passing the comedy record of 13 set by “The Studio” last year. The Apple TV series had already collected 8 awards at an earlier ceremony.

Hiro Murai, Katie Dippold, and Matthew Rhys posing together in the press room at the 78th Primetime Emmy Awards at Peacock Theatre in Los Angeles
Hiro Murai, Katie Dippold, and Matthew Rhys — all winners for “Widow’s Bay” — gather in the press room at the 78th Primetime Emmy Awards held at Peacock Theatre in Los Angeles on September 14, 2026. Photo by Frederic J. Brown / AFP via Getty Images.

The first-season show follows a New England island community confronting a centuries-old curse, with Matthew Rhys playing the mayor. Creator Katie Dippold called it a “crazy, creative swing” while accepting best comedy series, adding, “They truly just let us do this weird show.”

Rhys won lead actor in a comedy and lead actor in a limited series for “The Beast in Me,” making him the first man to win 2 leading actor categories in the same year. He earned a third trophy as an executive producer of “Widow’s Bay.”

Cast and crew of Widow's Bay posing with the Outstanding Comedy Series Emmy Award in the press room at the 78th Primetime Emmy Awards
The “Widow’s Bay” ensemble — including Jeff Hiller, Matthew Rhys, Dale Dickey, Kingston Rumi Southwick, Kevin Carroll, Stephen Root, Kate O’Flynn, and Neil Casey — hold their Outstanding Comedy Series award at the 78th Primetime Emmys press room on September 14, 2026. Photo by Amy Sussman / Getty Images.

The show also won comedy writing for Dippold and directing for Hiro Murai. Stephen Root and Kate O’Flynn took the supporting acting awards, giving both performers their first Emmys. At 74, Root became the category’s oldest winner.

Matthew Rhys at the Apple TV Emmy nominees party at NYA Studios West in Hollywood
Matthew Rhys at the Apple TV+ Emmy nominees celebration held at NYA Studios West in Hollywood on September 14, 2026. Photo by Unique Nicole / AFP via Getty Images.

Apple TV has now won best comedy series in 4 of the past 6 seasons across “Widow’s Bay,” “The Studio” and “Ted Lasso.”

Meet The Author