In Obsession, Bear’s Cat Dies Before His Wish, Then Nikki Finds a Use for Her Remains

Updated

A still from the 2026 film Obsession.

In Obsession, Bear’s cat, Sandy, dies after eating the pills he’s left within reach. When he finds her on the kitchen floor, an open pill bottle sits among spilled cat food and opened cans.

silver tabby kitten on floor
A silver tabby kitten rests on the floor (via Unsplash).

The medication belonged to his grandmother. Sandy’s death is an accident, but the scene establishes Bear’s carelessness before he ever makes his wish.

Scene from the 2026 film Obsession
A still from Obsession (2026). (via Unsplash)

Bear (Michael Johnston) then uses a supernatural toy called the One Wish Willow to make his longtime crush, Nikki (Inde Navarrette), love him more than anyone else. He gets the devotion he asked for while the real Nikki becomes trapped beneath an obsessive version of herself.

Sandy’s remains become part of that obsession. Nikki makes a memorial with them, then puts them in a sandwich for Bear’s lunch.

silver tabby kitten on floor
A silver tabby kitten rests on the floor (via Unsplash).
Tabby cat sat with legs tucked underneath and eyes closed
A tabby cat rests in a loaf position with eyes closed on a soft gray surface. (via Unsplash)
1 / 2

Meet the author

Chrissy Stockton

Chrissy is the co-founder of Creepy Catalog. She has over 10 years of experience writing about horror, a degree in philosophy and Reiki level II certification.