Underwhelmed by the First Take of Henry Winkler’s Death Scene in Scream, Wes Craven Asked, “Do You Think It Might Be More Excruciating?”

Middle-aged man with graying hair in a tan blazer looking back over his shoulder with a worried expression, film still from Scream (1996).

Henry Winkler will readily admit he is not a horror fan. Despite playing Principal Arthur Himbry in Wes Craven’s 1996 slasher classic ‘Scream,’ the actor says he’s never actually seen the finished film — he watched the premiere through his fingers.

Henry Winkler smiling at a premiere event, wearing a plaid shirt and herringbone blazer, with a teal step-and-repeat backdrop behind him.
At Hollywood Legion Theater in Los Angeles on June 23, 2026, Henry Winkler steps out for the HBO premiere of ‘Life, Larry and The Pursuit of Unhappiness.’ Photo by Leon Bennett / Getty Images.

Winkler landed the small but memorable role through his friendship with Craven, who invited him aboard and tucked a few Easter eggs from Winkler’s “Happy Days” era into the character. Himbry’s first name is Arthur — a nod to Arthur “Fonzie” Fonzarelli — and a leather bomber jacket can be spotted hanging in his closet.

A man in a suit and tie stands between two students with black hoods over their heads in a wood-paneled school office, pointing at one of them.
Principal Himbry confronts two hooded students in his wood-paneled office in a tense scene from Wes Craven’s ‘Scream’ (1996).

The role also gave Winkler one of the more memorable death scenes in the movie. He recently told PEOPLE that on the first take, blood shot out of tubes rigged all over his body as he screamed and hit the floor.

Craven, however, was underwhelmed.

The director walked over to Winkler after the take and asked, “Do you think it might be more excruciating?”

A tall man in a houndstooth blazer and patterned tie stands next to a shorter smiling young woman in a blue shirt inside a wood-paneled school office.
Principal Himbry towers over a smiling young woman in a school hallway in this wide shot from ‘Scream’ (1996).

Winkler said yes. He took a shower, got retubed, and ran the whole thing again. “I screamed my head off,” he recalled. Horror fan or not, he has no regrets about the experience: “I had the greatest time,” he said of making ‘Scream.’

Close-up of a middle-aged man in a suit with a guarded, stern expression, looking over his shoulder in a dimly lit interior.
A close-up captures Principal Himbry’s wary, tight-lipped expression in a hallway scene from ‘Scream’ (1996).

Craven died in 2015 at the age of 76. ‘Scream’ turns 30 this December.

Meet The Author