In the X-Files Episode ‘the List,’ a Dead Inmate Gets His Revenge and Mulder and Scully Never Solve the Case

Updated

A still from The X-Files episode "The List"

In The X-Files episode “The List,” a death row inmate vows revenge after his execution, and Mulder and Scully leave without solving the murders. Before his execution, Florida inmate Napoleon “Neech” Manley promises he’ll return from the dead to kill 5 men who tormented him. As the agents head home, his revenge is still unfolding.

The investigation begins when a guard turns up dead in Neech’s former cell. Another guard’s severed head is later discovered in a paint can. Both deaths involve larvae, with the first victim’s lungs infested and the second showing decay far ahead of what Scully expects.

A still from The X-Files episode "The List"
A scene from The X-Files episode “The List,” in which Mulder and Scully investigate a series of prison murders tied to a death row inmate’s vow of revenge. Credit: The X-Files.

Warden Brodeur suspects Neech arranged the killings before he died. Mulder finds evidence of Neech’s fixation on reincarnation, while Scully pursues the possibility of a conspiracy.

An inmate named Roque offers information about the remaining targets in exchange for a transfer. Brodeur refuses, then beats him to death after Roque names the warden as the final target.

A still from The X-Files episode "The List"
A scene from The X-Files episode “The List,” in which Mulder and Scully investigate a series of prison murders tied to a death row inmate’s vow of revenge. Credit: The X-Files.

The deaths extend beyond the prison. Mulder and Scully find Neech’s executioner decomposing in his attic, and Neech returns to suffocate his former lawyer. The agents eventually focus on guard Vincent Parmelly, who’s secretly involved with Neech’s widow, Danielle.

After seeing Neech at her bedroom door, Danielle becomes convinced he’s returned in Parmelly’s body. She shoots Parmelly as law enforcement arrives.

A still from The X-Files episode "The List"
A scene from The X-Files episode “The List,” in which Mulder and Scully investigate a series of prison murders tied to a death row inmate’s vow of revenge. Credit: The X-Files.

Parmelly gets the blame for the murders, but Mulder sees holes in that explanation: the guard was working during only 1 killing, and he wasn’t among the 3 men who knew the executioner’s identity. Scully persuades Mulder to leave the case behind.

As they prepare to drive home, Brodeur passes them. Neech appears in the warden’s car and attacks him, sending it into a tree and killing his final target.

Chris Carter wrote and directed the episode, which aired on October 20, 1995. Story editor Frank Spotnitz later singled out its unresolved investigation as a deliberate choice: “Mulder and Scully do not solve the case, and that is something I had been interested in doing for some time.”

A still from The X-Files episode "The List"
A scene from The X-Files episode “The List,” in which Mulder and Scully investigate a series of prison murders tied to a death row inmate’s vow of revenge. Credit: The X-Files.
A still from The X-Files episode "The List"
A scene from The X-Files episode “The List,” in which Mulder and Scully investigate a series of prison murders tied to a death row inmate’s vow of revenge. Credit: The X-Files.
A still from The X-Files episode "The List"
A scene from The X-Files episode “The List,” in which Mulder and Scully investigate a series of prison murders tied to a death row inmate’s vow of revenge. Credit: The X-Files.
A man seated in an electric chair has a metal execution helmet fitted onto his head by two guards in prison uniforms.
Guards fasten an execution helmet onto condemned inmate Napoleon “Neech” Manley in a scene from The X-Files episode “The List.” Credit: The X-Files.
1 / 4

Meet the author

Chrissy Stockton

Chrissy is the co-founder of Creepy Catalog. She has over 10 years of experience writing about horror, a degree in philosophy and Reiki level II certification.