Haymitch watching Katniss earn an 11 in The Hunger Games carries a different weight after Sunrise on the Reaping reveals his connection to her father. Burdock Everdeen was his childhood best friend. The girl he’s mentoring is that friend’s daughter, showing the Capitol a defiant streak Haymitch knows well.
Katniss earns that score after the Gamemakers barely pay attention during her private evaluation. She sends an arrow through the apple in a roasted pig’s mouth at their table, then leaves with a pointed “Thank you for your consideration.” They give her the highest training score of any tribute that year.

Haymitch is delighted. In the original book, he explains that her temper makes her appealing to the people putting on the Games. He understands how that kind of fire can help her hold their attention, and how attention can help keep a tribute alive.
His own defiance came at a devastating price. After he won the 50th Hunger Games, Snow had his mother, brother and girlfriend, Lenore Dove, killed. By Katniss’s Games, he’s spent roughly 24 years mentoring District 12 children and watching them die.
That history gives Woody Harrelson’s reaction another possible meaning: hope from someone who’s learned how dangerous hope can be. Reading that feeling into his expression is an interpretation, and the score doesn’t establish that he suddenly stops drinking.
His growing investment in Katniss and Peeta has concrete stakes. He works on strategy and sponsors to give them a chance to survive, now with his best friend’s daughter among the children in his care.







